{"repo":"xf686/Meet-Reviewer-2","free":true,"listed":false,"github":"https://github.com/xf686/Meet-Reviewer-2","clone":"git clone https://github.com/xf686/Meet-Reviewer-2.git","description":"Meet Reviewer 2 before they meet you ！ A Claude Code skill that red-teams your paper draft — a simulated peer-review panel + an evidence-grounded fix list, before you submit.","language":null,"stars":42,"topics":["academic","academic-skills","arxiv","claude-code","claude-skill","llm","machine-learning","paper","peer-review","rebuttal"],"license":"MIT","category":"machine-learning","readme_excerpt":"Reviewer 2 🔪 Meet Reviewer 2 before they meet you. 在 Reviewer 2 找上你之前,先让他帮你挑一遍。 English · 中文 ↓ Point it at your paper draft. It simulates a full peer-review panel — the generous champion, the brutal Reviewer 2 , and a novelty-hawk Area Chair — predicts the reviews you'll get, and hands you a prioritized, evidence-grounded fix list. Every criticism is pinned to a line in your draft. No invented flaws. A Claude Code skill for researchers who'd rather get torn apart in private. --- The problem You already know the feeling. You submit. Three months later, Reviewer 2 writes the words that sink your paper: \"The baselines are weak and the improvements are not statistically significant. Reject.\" The brutal part: most of those wounds were self-inflicted and fixable — a missing baseline, an un-controlled confound, an overclaim in the abstract, a number with no error bars. You just didn't have a hostile reader before the deadline. reviewer-2 is that hostile reader. It runs the panel on your draft now , while you can still fix things. What it does You give it a draft ( .pdf , .tex , .md , an arXiv link, or pasted text). It produces a red-team report : 1. Simulated reviews from a panel that genuinely disagrees with itself — - 🫶 R1, The Champion — finds your real contribution (and calibrates what's actually strong: where even R1 can't praise, you're weak). - 🔪 R2, The Methodological Skeptic — the one you're afraid of. Hunts weak baselines, missing ablations, confounds, cherry-picking, o","default_branch":null,"files":null,"tree":[],"storefront":"/r/xf686","claimed":false,"request_supported":{"post":"https://gitbuyer.com/r/xf686/Meet-Reviewer-2/request-supported","requests":0},"note":"indexed from public GitHub; nothing is for sale on this page. Clone it from GitHub. Paid listings live at /search."}